Return to the Reviews Page
Archives
   Birds of Prey #39
   Birds of Prey #40


Feedback
This reviewer is open to getting feedback e-mail from readers. You may email him at:

jjacobse@columbus.rr.com

Birds of Prey #40
Joel Jacobsen
Title: Switchback
Cover Date: April 2002
Story: Chuck Dixon
Pencils: Rick Leonardi
Inks: Jesse Delperdang
Colors and Separations: Wildstorm FX


Overall impression:


This issue is part of the current crossover in the Batman universe, comprising Part Twelve of the Bruce Wayne: Murderer? Storyline. As with last month, there are some major developments for that story, and again, the story carries the art, but the art did noticeably improve I felt. (See Technical Impressions). Also like last month, it's not really a good starting point, but the over all story revolving around Black Canary and Spoiler could be a stand-alone story. You just have to read past the other plot hooks spliced throughout the issue.

Technical impression:

Cover: (4 of 5 cowls)

Phil Noto treats us to another cover this month. I really like his style and actually find myself wishing he were doing the pencils all the way through and not just the covers. Sigh.

Story: (3 of 5 cowls)

Chuck Dixon must have had a total fixation with Black Canary's lost Canary Cry. I know of at least a half dozen uses since it's return last fall. This is just off the top of my head and I don't really want to know how close I am on that count. I fear I'm counting low. It's used twice in this issue. It was used twice in January. Yes, she has it back. We know she has it back. But she's gotten along without it for how long? Geesh. She can kick tail and take names with the best of the best and she's relying on her newly regained meta-powers. And why? In Issue 38, it made some sense and didn't bother me. But c'mon. Think the story through a little better next time and stop leaning on the super power button so much, please. Then there are some plot holes in the story. Little things like chasing off Riddler and Cluemaster without even trying to apprehend them. Did I miss a new rule that says you aren't supposed to arrest criminals if you see them in at home?

Art: (3 of 5 cowls)

Rick Leonardi has bought himself another month before I make a final decision on his penciling. There is noticeable - and needed - improvement over last month's eyesore. But I'm still not satisfied. Page 8 has the best drawings of Dinah in the whole issue. They're still not great, but I can live with it if he can keep it at this level. Sadly, he hasn't, yet. His character work in general has improved, with the possible exception of The Riddler. And the horrible 'overlaid' plaid is back on Ted's shirt this issue.

The coloring isn't bad in this issue. In fact it seems a little brighter than last month. I like it over all and have no real complaints.


General Story overview:

Black Canary and Spoiler return from Vesper Fairchild's apartment with the evidence they found. It may have direct implicates on her murder and who may have done it. While there, Dinah finds out about Stephanie's delicate home life with her father being the Cluemaster and having The Riddler shacked up with him. Ted informs Barbara about the results of his doctor's appointment and finds a gift in his Kordtronics office. Black Canary and Spoiler set off to rid the Brown household of deadbeats and criminals, with Canary doing all the work (and short work at that) herself. Barbara and Robin come to some realization about the gun that Bruce Wayne bought and probably why he did it to begin with. Ted soon finds out that his gift isn't such a light hearted or user friendly device and suddenly has a very valid reason to go against his doctor's orders of no strenuous physical activity. And to complicate things in case they weren't already complicated enough, Bruce Wayne escapes from jail.

Full Story review (contains spoilers):

The story opens with Black Canary and Spoiler returning from Vesper Fairchild's apartment with the tapes and other things pertaining to her investigation into the mysterious Batman sightings. Spoiler seems to assume that because she's there, she's "in" on the mission. Canary seems to feel that she can't well tell the girl to buzz off so she tolerates her. Oracle determines it'll take her hours to go through all of the evidence and the issue of Stephanie's home situation comes up. Dinah reluctantly goes along with the girl to try and figure out what she can do to help.

As they leave, Ted Kord calls and informs Barbara of his heart condition and that he won't be putting on the Blue Beetle suit again any time soon. He thanks her for forcing him to go to the doctor and figure out what has been going on. He also offers to meet up with her later over a cup of decaf coffee, no milk or sugar. While in his office, he finds a large package (the size of a large computer monitor box), and wonders if Barbara sent the large mechanical spider-thing inside as some sort of "get well" gift.

We then cut to Dinah and Stephanie speeding down the road. Steph tells Dinah that her father is the notorious Cluemaster, he knows she runs around as Spoiler, the Riddler has shacked up with her dad, and Batman isn't anywhere to be found to try and help. Stephanie asks if Dinah knows where the Dark Knight is, and we get another indication that two and two are being put together when Dinah replies, "Not really. But I have a few ideas."

Meanwhile, Robin and Oracle are going over the Fairchild interview tapes and begin to piece together that she probably knew who Batman really was and that it was Bruce. They also surmise, which takes little effort, that if she knew Batman's secret identity, it was probably why she was murdered. And then the realization hits - if someone hired her to dig into this, which was very possible, then someone else may well know everyone else's identities.

Spoiler and Black Canary recon the house. They see Echo and Query and then Riddler and Cluemaster. The latter are both going over blueprints or schematics. Dinah finally realizes just how serious Stephanie's home situation is. Her dad's name is on the mortgage, her mother doesn't know her father has threatened to kill her and she's afraid to even tell her mom she's been doing the vigilante deal. She admits they just put up with it because there isn't much else they can do. Wrong. Dinah doesn't even wait. She slides down the snow-covered roof they were on top of and heads for the front door. As soon as the door opens she pulls out the Canary Cry and incapacitates the two female thugs. The Riddler (out of costume) pulls what appears to be a .38 special on Black Canary (what? A wheel gun? Is that all big time crooks can afford these days? Times must be tough….). She pulls out the stops and lets loose a second Cry. This one causes the gun to vibrate apart. She then delivers the ultimatum. She's the Black Canary. Get out and don't come back or the JLA will show up and open up a worse can of whoop-ass on them than she did. And that's that. They pack their car and take off.

Ted Kord gets a call from the mysterious Mr. Quam who is trying to effect a "Hostile takeover" of Kordtronics. Little Charles, the spider-mech-thingy is an assassin-bot and proceeds to try and dispatch Ted, blasting his desk to bits. So much for lack of excitement in his life.

We then see Robin and Oracle discussing the fact Bruce bought the gun himself. That Barbara has worked passed her fear of guns after being shot by Joker but maybe, just maybe, Bruce hasn't. And then they hear word from the news that Bruce Wayne has escaped from jail and is a fugitive of justice. Barbara calls Dick, as Robin leaves to confront Bruce directly. Dick heard the news and is en route to the Bat Cave. What happens next, appears in Batman 600.

[Top]