Return to the Reviews Page
Archives
   Batgirl #25
   Batgirl #26


Feedback
Do you have questions or comments about this review? Post them on the Sasha Bordeaux Fan Site ezboard by clicking HERE.

Batgirl #26
Ponder
Title: Untitled
Cover Date: March 2002
Story: Scott Peterson
Pencils: Vincent Giarrano
Inks: Jesse Delperdang
Colors and Separations: Jason Wright / Digital Chameleon


Synopsis: (WARNING! SPOILERS!)

The story opens up with the last few minutes of the fight between Batgirl and Shiva from Batgirl 25 and then turns to the Clocktower where Spoiler and Oracle look in on a sleeping Cassandra. Apparently four days have passed between issue 25 and this one during which Batgirl must have appeared in Batman 600 though her face lacks the injuries she'd shown there.

With Cassandra laid up in bed, Spoiler decides she's the best candidate when one of Shiva's followers kidnaps a woman in order to call out whoever had defeated Shiva. Spoiler's doubts in her ability to actually do this despite her bravado towards Oracle comes in the form of a Batgirlformed from her subconscious. The normally untalkative figure now seems to have lot to say as she gives Spoiler the confidence to do this.

The follower seems to actually believe Spoiler is the one who defeated Shiva until he manages to hit her and then it becomes quite obvious to him that this is not the one he seeks. Instead of receiving the honorable death he was seeking instead Shiva's temple has been defiled and he attempts to kill Spoiler. Spoiler however gets in a lucky blow and the fight is ended and she returns to the Clocktower.



Analysis:

Cover
: (4 of 5 cowls)

The gray colored Batgirl on the cover gives a foreshadowing of what lies within without giving away any of the story. The damage to Spoiler is more realistic of the fight then the apparent lack of injuries within.


Story: (3 of 5 cowls)

More of a fill in issue then anything else. The issue focuses on Spoiler with only a few token appearances by Batgirl via Spoiler's subconscious. The main shining point of this issue is the relationship between Spoiler and Batgirl as she talks to Batgirl but also from her initial conversation with Oracle.


Artwork: (3 of 5 cowls)

Compared to the almost manga feel this book normally carries this issue was rather cartoon like in comparison with only the villain carrying any of the books normal feel in the way he was drawn. The lack of injuries to Spoiler is a major error in the artwork from my point of view considering most of the issue surrounds the fact Spoiler doesn't think she's up to the task and takes some blows and kicks during the fight.

[Top]