Return to the Reviews Page
Archives
   Batman #599
   Batman #600
  Batman #601
  Batman #602
  Batman #603
  Batman #604
  Batman #605

Feedback
This reviewer is open to getting feedback e-mail from readers. You may email her at:

haines@ev1.net

Batman #602
Bridget Haines
Title: Turning the Town Red - Pt. 2 of 2
Cover Date: June 2002
Story: Ed Brubaker
Pencils: Scott McDaniel
Inks: Andy Owens
Colors and Separations: Gregory Wright / Wildstorm FX


Synopsis: (WARNING! SPOILERS!)

The second part of the saga involving new meta-villain Nicodemus unforlds with an image of the mayor of Gotham chained to the front of a runaway subway train. Nicodemus renders his warning to the city proper, that it will be destroyed because it is evil. Batman watches from his auxilliary cave as Commissioner Akins speaks to the public about the threatm then lets Thomas Hart be hero-ized for surviving being kidnapped (last issue). Hart taunts the villain to come to the memorial on Sundat for Jack McKenna and to honor Hart.

The Bat internalizes as he reviews his evidence thus far. He decides there is a deeper connection between the victims. Hart is idealized on the news. Flash to the next part of the Bat trying to save the mayor. Flash forward to the Child Welfare office where Batman looks up records on Hart. Batman catches a clue, but the reader isn't clued in to it just yet.

The lights go out at the banquet as Hart takes the podium. Batman stops to talk to a paramedic. The paramedic tells Batman that someone had not a hair on his whole body. It appears that hands reach out in flames to grasp Hart's head, killing him. Batman arrives to see Nicodemus standing over the burning corpse. He grabs the mayor and escapes.

Batman rushes to the call about the kidnapped mayor and now we catch up in time to theopening of the book. He stops the subway car, saving the mayor, who claims to know who Nicodemus is. So does Batman.,

It turns out Thomas Hart is Nicodemus, and the guy who died at the banquet was the one who sat beside him during it. His parents were killed and the murder covered up. So that throws Nicodemus out of the knowing Bruce Wayne is the Bat running. Last issues initial monologue was self referential, and not about Batman afterall. Hart had a shrine in his basement, and a letter to the Bat saying he'd see him again soon.



Analysis:

Cover
: (3 of 5 cowls)

Not a bad cover, but not McD's best by a longshot. The deposed Nicodemus was not an indicator of the internal story. Old Nico did pretty well for himself in it. The looming bat silhouette is nice though, and I like the green in the background for some reason. Other than that, the composition and elements are kind of weak.


Story: (4 of 5 cowls)

Ed is still the man. I really have enjoyed the Nicodemus storyline, and was so busy looking to see who he was that he know about Bruce from the beginning of last issue, that I was blindsided by Hart referring to himself. Nice twisted plotline, I liked it a lot. Though I would have liked to have seen a smidgeon of reference to the BW:F storyline in there somewhere.


Artwork: (5 of 5 cowls)

McDaniel...need I say more. He's a master visual storyteller and he is no less so here. I am curious as to which DC book he will be moving to when Lee and Loeb take over the reins of Batman for 12 issues?.

[Top]